Woman Forced To Get Rid Of Pets
Nov 21st, 2007 by admin
Clipped from the St.Catharines Standard Newspaper
A devastated St. Catharines cat owner says she’ll try to find another affordable apartment after a judge ruled she has to evict her pets.
“They’re all I got. It’s not fair. It’s not right,” said Joanne Kinslow through tears, after being told Tuesday that she lost her case to keep Shadow and Oreo in her rented unit at 215 Glenridge Ave.
“I’ve got 90 days to get rid of my cats. To me it’s a bad decision. My friend can keep her cats and I have to get rid of mine.”
Superior Court Justice Joseph Quinn wrote in his decision that Kinslow gave him no legitimate basis to rule against her condominium corporation’s no-pets declaration.
She “demonstrated a preference, not a need, for her cats,” he wrote in the ruling handed down this month.
“The rights and expectations of the unit owners should not be compromised by the mere preference of an occupant. The cats must go.”
It was a very different outcome for Kinslow than it was for another tenant in the same building who won the right to keep her cats in 2005.
“I find it a little strange that with almost the identical two … situations with the same judge, he would reach a different decision,” Kinslow’s lawyer, Terry Kirby, said Tuesday.
Kinslow has been fighting to keep her cats since January 2006, when she received a letter from the building’s condo corporation telling her to comply with the no-pets policy.
Kinslow has a brain injury and bipolar disorder and said the cats make her feel better and have a calming effect.
When she didn’t get rid of the cats, the Niagara North Condominium Corp. sent three more letters to no effect.

